Bath Control - Intermediate

Trivalent vs hexavalent chromate: cost, color, salt spray | QLQ

The question every buyer asks

Misconception: the belief "trivalent passivation is much worse than hexavalent" has shifted over a decade to "essentially equivalent" — modern trivalent + sealers reach 150–250h to white rust.

This page answers Trivalent vs hexavalent chromate: cost, color, salt spray — a top recurring question from real QLQ customers — with the line-level detail our technicians actually use. Parameters are industry-standard starting ranges; confirm against your supplier TDS.

Trivalent vs hexavalent chromate: cost, color, salt spray - QLQ workshop photo
QLQ workshop — QLQ workshop photo

Reference table

SystemSalt sprayCostComplianceMisuse risk
Hex iridescent zincbenchmark 96–200hlowrestricted in EU/USexporting with Cr⁶⁺ → rejected
Trivalent + sealer150–250h white rust2–4xRoHS friendlybare trivalent without sealer → degraded
Olive drabhigh corrosion resistancelowhex only"trivalent olive drab" on a drawing = nonexistent
Trivalent vs hexavalent chromate: cost, color, salt spray - QLQ workshop photo
Process close-up — QLQ workshop photo

How we handle it on the line

  • The real discussion is compliance necessity and cost, not vague performance folklore.
  • Definitions: hexavalent passivation = traditional iridescent/olive zinc, strong performance but Cr⁶⁺ is highly toxic and restricted by RoHS/REACH; trivalent = ~1/100 the toxicity, + sealer restores performance; decorative chrome plating is a separate trivalent/hexavalent bath question.
  • Options: QLQ's in-house plating shop runs both systems — traditional for domestic/unrestricted markets to save cost; trivalent + sealer with RoHS reports for EU/US exports.
  • Callout trap: trivalent films differ slightly in hue from hexavalent — lock a color reference plate at sampling to avoid mixed-line color drift.
  • Ask: 1) is my target market Cr⁶⁺-restricted?
  • 2) what trivalent cost premium is acceptable?

Honest boundaries

  • 3) does the vendor have measured trivalent salt-spray data (not brochure numbers)?
  • Honest boundary: mild degradation of trivalent films over time is normal; "Cr⁶⁺ degrades away so it doesn't matter" is a debunked myth.
  • Next step: tell QLQ your target market; we reply with system selection and a measured-report sample.

FAQ

Can QLQ provide test reports with the delivery?
Yes — salt spray, thickness and adhesion reports are attached per lot on request.
Can QLQ provide test reports with the delivery?
Yes — salt spray, thickness and adhesion reports are attached per lot on request.
Can QLQ provide test reports with the delivery?
Yes — salt spray, thickness and adhesion reports are attached per lot on request.
Previous Post
Electroplating job pricing: by area or by weight? | QLQ
Next Post
White rust, red rust, salt frost: identify before you blame | QLQ